Be careful what you wish for. ‘Right to forget’ beginning to backfire



Based on an EU court ruling Google has begun removing links to stories that people have requested be removed from search results. But the stories are beginning to get more attention than ever before.

Google began removing links to certain stories in European search results based on requests people have made claiming that the stories were “inadequate, irrelevant or no longer relevant.” That’s what the EU court ordered them to do.

But Google also began sending emails to the publishers of the stories informing them that the links were being removed.

BBC’s economics editor Robert Peston received the following notice:

Notice of removal from Google Search: we regret to inform you that we are no longer able to show the following pages from your website in response to certain searches on European versions of Google:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/legacy/thereporters/robertpeston/2007/10/merrills_mess.html

Peston was curious about which article was being 'dissapeared' and who might have made the request. Turns out the only person mentioned in the 2007 article was former Merrill Lynch chairman Stan O'Neal.

Peston promptly wrote a piece about Google’s email and O’Neal’s request to be forgotten.

And that piece got picked up by a whole slew of websites following the ‘right to be forgotten’ issue. And so on, and so on.

The Guardian also received notices from Google about six of their articles. And they too wrote new articles about what the original articles were about and who were the people requesting to be forgotten.

And that story got picked up too.

I applaud Google for doing this. They are following the letter of the law as the EU court has ordered them to but they’ve also unleashed the wrath of some fairly large European media giants.

Years ago, when I was Editor-in-Chief of AmigaWorld magazine, I had a little sign over my desk that read, “It is never, ever a good idea to piss off an editor.”



Guy Wright

Guy Wright has been covering the technology space since the days when computers had cranks and networks were steam powered. He has been a writer and editor for more years then he cares to admit.


More

Microsoft Moves To Replace TV With Hololens: From The Super Bowl To Quidditch

If you didn’t turn in early to the Super Bowl you likely missed one of the most fascinating ads . This ad was a showcase of how Microsoft’s Hololens , which is in developer preview, could be used to transform TV watching. Unlike Google Glass which shines an image into your eye and provides a semi-transparent overlay Hololens is designed to fully alter what you see and hear so that you could put yourself in the position of quarterback, receiver, line, center, referee, or in the best seats in the stadium which could dynamically change based on the action. In fact the only thing you’ll miss is...

Able2Extract, a PDF wizard everyone needs

I am sure most of us have encountered the situation where you receive a PDF, but there is a typo, a wrong reference, something is missing or the data is wrong. And if you have ever tried to edit a PDF, you know what a pain it can be.

AMD And The Forgotten Benefits Of The Desktop PC

One of the interesting things I’ve been observing with regard to the near forced march to mobile devices is the increased need for a desktop computer where you can just sit and get work done. With all of the background sync capability in the various platforms provided by Amazon, Apple, Microsoft and others the old annoying problems of keeping you files in sync across multiple devices is pretty much over. You can pretty easily start creation on one device today and finish it on another. Gaming, although clearly increasingly focused on mobile devices, still favors desktop computers for the most...