Supreme Court should rule on Aereo case this week

Supreme Court should rule on Aereo case this week

In a contentious case before the Supreme Court that could be construed as hair-splitting, Aereo’s fate could be decided sometime this week.

The case, on the surface, seems fairly straightforward yet there are a few subtleties upon which the case may be decided.

Aereo offers a service to ‘cord cutters’ (people wishing to discontinue their cable or satellite services in favor of other types of providers) where they basically pay around $8 per month for a dedicated over-the-air (OTA) receiver installed in their geographic coverage area. Subscribers also have access to a cloud-based digital video recorder (DVR). Subscribers can’t access OTA markets outside their immediate area, say for circumventing sports blackouts.

Essentially Aereo is offering subscribers exactly the same thing they would get if they set up their own digital antenna and connected it to a store-bought DVR.

Not surprisingly, all the major networks and Fox, think this is a terribly bad idea. They contend that Aereo is re-broadcasting their content without permission or paying the same fees that cable and satellite providers pay the networks. They also say that by combining the OTA service with the DVR subscribers would be able to skip commercials and therefor broadcasters wouldn’t be able to charge advertisers the same amount.

The case is reminiscent of the networks’ attempts to block the sale of VCRs when they first came out and their later attempts to block the sale of DVRs. In both cases the courts ruled that people have the right to record whatever they want on their VCRs and time-shift all they want with their DVRs – they just can’t re-broadcast those shows or charge people to watch them.

Using the standard end-of-the-world arguments, Fox executive Chase Carey threatened to end over-the-air OTA broadcasts if the Supreme Court ruled in Aereo’s favor. "We will move to a subscription model if that’s our only recourse,” Carey said.

It is interesting to note that when the television industry made the transition to digital broadcasts only back in the mid 2000s the FCC went out of its way to make sure that they weren’t leaving anyone behind and offered coupons for analog rabbit ear users to upgrade to digital rabbit ears. But even with the new rabbit ears not every user was able to pick up local stations.

Aereo’s original idea was to locate digital rabbit ears in optimal locations so users who couldn’t get the full range of stations would be able to access all those free, OTA stations.

So what exactly is the difference between what Aereo does and me renting a digital receiver and DVR at a local Rent-a-Center then mounting the antenna on top of my neighbor’s ham radio antenna for a few bucks a month? Theoretically the OTA broadcasts are free if I use my own antenna (even if I rent it) and the Supreme Court has already ruled that DVRs are legal.

I realize that the networks’ revenues have been slipping for decades (primarily due to fragmentation of the market now that viewers can pick from hundreds of channels) and it is likely to dwindle even more now that online content streaming services are attracting an increasingly larger number of eyeballs every day. But attacking a small company that provides a way for users to access a free service they are already entitled to smacks of desperation.

Guy Wright

Guy Wright has been covering the technology space since the days when computers had cranks and networks were steam powered. He has been a writer and editor for more years then he cares to admit.


AMD vs. Intel-Assessing Their New Strategies: A Study In Contrasts

Over the next few years we are going to see something we don’t see that often. Two companies in the same market on two very different paths. AMD will be focused like a laser on traditional PC and Server markets but adapting to the new loads and tasks that both are being tossed in. Intel, in contrast, will be expanding massively to drones, IoT, and Automotive each of which has massive, but as yet, unrealized potential for firms in their class. Now typically when AMD and Intel run at each other AMD is massively disadvantaged but with Intel’s shift in focus they won’t be chasing Intel but a...

Black Holes are sending quantum messages in the universe

Spinning black holes are capable of complex quantum information processes encoded in the X-ray photons emitted by the accretion disk.

5 In-Demand Online Money Making Ideas That Require More Than Just Geeky Brainpower

There’s certainly no shortage of money making ideas on the Internet. These ideas require a combination of skills that are so far apart in nature, that not many people boast them. In fact, 51% of jobs now require a combination of creative and technical skills.