Jammie Thomas's attorney says $222,000 award is unconstitutional

  • Duluth (MN) - The single mother ordered to pay nearly a quarter of a million dollars for sharing 24 songs is continuing her legal battle, asking the legal system to reconsider the verdict.

    Jammie Thomas became the guinea pig for a legal battle that has been riddled with questions, as the first person in the US to go to trial over illegally sharing music files.  Despite a seeming lack of evidence and even some confusion with the judge, a jury ordered her to pay $222,000 to the Recording Industry Association of America.

    Thomas's attorney Brian Toder is continuing to fight, though, and this week filed a motion to have a new trial to determine if the large verdict is unconstitutional.  Toder argued that the RIAA's actual damages were less than $151.20.  After all, those same 24 songs only have a face value of around $24.

    Ever since the case went to trial, Thomas became something of a celebrity, making headlines around the world and netting her her own Wikipedia entry.  Thomas has set up a website, FreeJammie.com, for people to make donations.  As of October 13, she reported her total donations to be nearly $14,000.

    The RIAA, meanwhile, has no sympathy for Thomas.  The trade group said, "We seek to resolve this case in a fair and reasonable manner.  It is unfortunate that the defendant continues to avoid responsibility for her actions. We will continue to defend our rights."

Related Stories

Have Disc Printing Technologies Become a Thing of the Past

Did You Know About the History of Montreal’s Olympic Stadium?

3 Safety Management Software Options for Businesses