UK spying on Google, Facebook etc. perfectly legal



The BBC News has reported that according to Charles Farr, director general of the Office for Security and Counter-Terrorism, spying on American-based search and social media traffic was perfectly legal under British law.

Farr told Privacy International that Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and web searches on Google - as well as webmail services such as Hotmail and Yahoo - were classified as "external communications," which meant they could be intercepted without specific warrants.

According to the BBC story:

Internal communications between citizens can only be intercepted when a targeted warrant is issued. Warrants must be signed by a minister and can only be issued when there is suspicion of illegal activity.

But when someone searches for something on Google or posts on Facebook they are sending information overseas - constituting an act of external communication that could be collected under a broader warrant which does not need to be signed by a minister, explained Mr Farr in a 48-page written statement.

But then, in what has to be one of the most absurd, side-stepping rationalizations Farr added that the data collected "cannot be read, looked at or listened to" except in strictly limited circumstances.

Mr Farr also said there was a "significant distinction" between intercepting material and a person actually reading, looking at or listening it.

Um…okay.

Eric King, deputy director of Privacy International, said the revelation showed that spy agencies operate under their own laws. "Intelligence agencies cannot be considered accountable to Parliament and to the public they serve when their actions are obfuscated through secret interpretations of Byzantine laws."

Privacy researcher Caspar Bowden suggested the British laws concerning spying on, but not reading communications that cross international borders might be just a bit obscurely worded. "Interpreting that section requires the unravelling of a triple-nested inversion of meanings across six cross-referenced subsections, linked to a dozen other cross-linked definitions, which are all dependent on a highly ambiguous 'notwithstanding'," he said.

So it’s alright to collect all that information but it’s not alright to read, look at or listen to it. Isn’t that a bit like saying you can make bootleg copies of a thousand movies and copies of 10,000 pop songs but it’s not actually illegal unless you watch the movies or listen to the songs?

You can read the full BBC story here.



Guy Wright

Guy Wright has been covering the technology space since the days when computers had cranks and networks were steam powered. He has been a writer and editor for more years then he cares to admit.


More

Top 5 Mobile Games for 2016

Mobile games are very much taking over every aspect of human life with people playing them at home, on the streets, in queues, in shops, at football matches, in the cinema, and even in the toilet. So many games are now being made available to play on mobile devices but which ones are the ones to watch out for in 2016? Crashlands Survival games seem to be a massive hit with players at the moment. This could perhaps be due to the success of television shows and movies such as The Walking Dead and The Martian but it is a genre that taps into the human instinct. A desire to survive in extreme...

Review: LeEco Le 2, Upping The Ante

Despite its lacklustre free content, the Le 2 is a compelling option to buy at its price.

How to Break Your Teen Out of the Tech Trance

If you’re asked where your teen is right now and what they are doing, you’d probably say “They are in their room using Facebook, streaming videos, or playing games”. Unfortunately, that’s pretty much the same story everywhere. The smartphone generation doesn’t seem to care a great deal about attaining good grades, having a social life, doing good in sports, or visiting places. All they ever want to do is stay lost in technology, browsing their social networking profiles, streaming videos, or playing games. This has almost become a lifestyle for them, something that you should really be...